1944, at Penn State University
95 pounds: George Lewis, sophomore, Farrell
112: Howdy Prizant, senior, Farrell

1949, at Lancaster
133 pounds: Gus DeAugustino, senior, Grove City
145: Ralph Schneider, senior, Academy

1964, at Penn State University
95 pounds: Robert Flint, senior, Hickory

1974, at Penn State University
Class B
103 pounds: Ray Frantz, senior, Cranberry
132: Dave Anthony, senior, Reynolds
185: Steve Riley, junior, Greenville
Note: 1974 was the first year the PIAA split the tournament into separate classes

1979, at Hershey
Class AAA
105 pounds: Kevin Darkus, junior, Cathedral Prep
145: Nate Carr, senior, Tech Memorial
Class AA
155 pounds: Randy McKinney, senior, Fairview
185: Kevin Klasic, senior, Reynolds

1984, at Hershey
Class AAA
112 pounds: Doug Sanford, senior, Meadville
Class AA
145 pounds: Ed Burkhart, senior, Corry

1989, at Hershey
Class AA
275 pounds: Aaron Armer, senior, Reynolds

1994, at Hershey
Class AAA
171 pounds: Bret Ruth, senior, Oil City
Class AA
103 pounds: Jonathan Hazi, senior, Reynolds
135: Casey Taylor, junior, Reynolds
189: Fred Scriven, senior, Commodore Perry

2004, at Hershey
Class AA
103 pounds: Kody Hiner, senior, Fort LeBoeuf